Gear

The Best Puppy Toys: Editorial Comparison for 2026

The right toys prevent 80% of unwanted chewing. Puppies need at least one option in each of four categories: teething, food-dispensing enrichment, tug, and destructible novelty. Below are the specific products our trainers hand out in first-week gear bags. No affiliate links.

Reviewed by Sarah Whitman, CPDT-KA Updated 2026-07-01

Editor's Pick

Kong Puppy (Rubber)

Best Value

Nylabone Puppy Chew

What matters when buying

Size

Any toy small enough to fit fully in the puppy's mouth is a choking hazard. Size up.

Material

Rubber (Kong, West Paw), nylon (Nylabone), rope (untreated cotton), plush (supervised only).

Supervision

Never leave a puppy alone with plush, rope, or destructible toys.

Rotation

Rotate 3–4 toys at a time and store the rest — novelty is what makes toys interesting.

Quick comparison

ProductRatingBest for
Kong Puppy (Rubber)Editor's PickThe single best all-purpose puppy toy
West Paw TopplRunner-UpFood-dispensing enrichment for meals
Nylabone Puppy ChewRecommendedStructured chewing outlet during teething (4–6 months)
Tether Tug or Cotton Rope (Supervised)RecommendedStructured tug for impulse control training

Editor's Pick

Kong Puppy (Rubber)

Best for: The single best all-purpose puppy toy

Pros

  • Freezes with wet food or yogurt for teething relief
  • Unpredictable bounce for fetch
  • Softer teething-rubber compound suits puppy teeth
  • Nearly indestructible in puppy jaws

Cons

  • Chewers over 6 months usually graduate to the adult Kong Classic
Material
Puppy-formula rubber
Sizes
XS – Large

If you buy one puppy toy, buy two of these. Stuffed and frozen, a Kong keeps a 10-week-old occupied for 30–45 minutes.

Runner-Up

West Paw Toppl

Best for: Food-dispensing enrichment for meals

Pros

  • Wide opening makes stuffing easy
  • Two sizes stack together for advanced puzzles
  • Non-toxic Zogoflex material
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Not as freezer-friendly as a Kong for teething
Material
Zogoflex
Sizes
Small, Large

Our favorite way to feed meals. Pair the small and large together for problem-solving as your puppy grows.

Recommended

Nylabone Puppy Chew

Best for: Structured chewing outlet during teething (4–6 months)

Pros

  • Softer 'puppy' formulation is safer than adult nylon
  • Flavored to stay interesting
  • Cheap

Cons

  • Not appropriate for adult heavy chewers — hardness can chip teeth
  • Some puppies ignore them entirely
Material
Puppy nylon

Only the puppy formulation. Never give a young puppy an adult Nylabone.

Recommended

Tether Tug or Cotton Rope (Supervised)

Best for: Structured tug for impulse control training

Pros

  • Teaches 'take it' and 'drop it' — foundational impulse control
  • Interactive with humans (bonding)
  • Great energy outlet for herding and terrier breeds

Cons

  • Frayed rope becomes ingestion risk
  • Never a chew toy left alone with the puppy
Material
Untreated cotton or rubber

Tug does not create aggression when played with rules. It's one of the best confidence-building games we teach.

Frequently asked

+ Are rawhide chews safe for puppies?

No. Rawhide can splinter, cause obstructions, and is often produced with concerning chemicals. Skip it entirely — better options exist.

+ Are antlers safe?

Split antlers rarely, but whole antlers frequently chip teeth. We don't recommend them for puppies under 12 months.

+ How many toys does a puppy need?

Rotate 4–6 toys at a time from a total stash of 12–15. Novelty is the point.

Continue learning