Fact-Checking Policy
Our standards and process for verifying every claim we publish.
Last updated June 1, 2026
What we verify
Before publication, every article on Pawpilot Journal is checked against three tiers of claims:
- Tier 1 — Medical, nutritional, and pharmacological claims. Must be sourced to AVMA, AAHA, WSAVA, FDA, peer-reviewed veterinary journals, or a board-certified veterinary specialist.
- Tier 2 — Behavioral and training claims. Must be sourced to peer-reviewed canine behavior research, AVSAB or IAABC position statements, or a credentialed behaviorist.
- Tier 3 — Practical claims. Trainer experience, equipment recommendations, and procedural advice. Must reflect current best practice and be reviewed by a credentialed editor.
Our review process
- Draft. A credentialed writer drafts the article with inline citations.
- Source check. A second editor verifies every Tier 1 and Tier 2 citation against the original source.
- Welfare review. The piece is reviewed against the LIMA framework and AVSAB/IAABC position statements.
- Copy edit. A copy editor reviews for clarity and reader-level accessibility.
- Sign-off. The senior editor approves the article before it is published.
Updates
Every article is reviewed at least once every 12 months. The "Updated" date on each article reflects the most recent substantive review, not minor copy edits.
Corrections
We correct factual errors as soon as they are confirmed. To submit a correction, email corrections@pawpilotjournal.com with the article URL, the specific claim, and a credible source supporting the correction. We confirm receipt within two business days and publish corrections within five business days when the source supports the change.
Material corrections — those that change the meaning of a recommendation — are noted with a dated correction at the bottom of the article. Minor corrections (typos, broken links) are made silently.
Conflicts of interest
Writers and reviewers disclose any financial relationship with a brand mentioned in their work. Where a real or perceived conflict exists, the piece is reassigned to a different reviewer.